Question:
Hi Jennifer,
Can I offer a warranty on my services?
Thanks,
Dr. J
Answer:
So, maybe. The warranty safe harbor is the star of today’s show. It is a regulatory exception to the Federal Anti-Kickback Statute for a bona fide warranty that meets specific conditions. In plain English, a provider or seller may promise to replace an item or service—or refund some or all of its cost—if the promised result is not achieved. If the warranty satisfies the safe harbor, the refund is not treated as illegal remuneration under the Anti-Kickback Statute. See 42 C.F.R. § 1001.952(g).
Ironically, a clinician who “warrants” a treatment result may be inviting a professional-misconduct charge. Yet federal fraud-and-abuse law has a safe harbor expressly built around a “warranty.” Put differently: the licensing rules warn, “Do not guarantee the outcome,” while the federal regulation says, “If you are going to refund the money when the outcome falls short, here is how to do it.” The safe harbor does not make a clinical guarantee permissible. It protects a carefully structured financial remedy, not a promise that treatment will work. Same word; very different legal consequence. For a discussion of the ethical and legal hazards of clinical guarantees, see “Caveat Promisor: The Potential Pitfalls of Clinical Guarantees.”
That protection matters because a refund has value, and anything of value offered to a patient can raise fraud-and-abuse questions. Calling a payment a “warranty” does not solve the problem. The arrangement has to operate like a real warranty: it must be in writing, state what is covered, explain the remedy, be part of the original bargain, and satisfy applicable disclosure and reporting requirements. It also cannot be a disguised reward for referrals or a hook that forces the patient to buy more services.
In OIG Advisory Opinion 26-12, the structure carried the day. The orthopedic surgeon offered a voluntary, one-year concierge program tied to recovery from an initial surgery. Patients enrolled before surgery under a written Membership Agreement and paid fair market value for non-covered services and products. A patient who substantially complied with the program but still required revision surgery within two years would receive a refund of the concierge fee. The refund was not tied to referrals. The patient was free to use another surgeon for the revision. There was no exclusivity or minimum-purchase requirement. The written agreement made the warranty part of the deal from the start and addressed the required reporting. Those facts allowed OIG to conclude that the arrangement fit the warranty safe harbor and would not generate prohibited remuneration under the Anti-Kickback Statute or the Beneficiary Inducements CMP.
Bottom line: The government has created a warranty safe harbor for a profession that generally should not be warranting results. That is the punchline—but not a loophole. The safe harbor may protect the refund; it does not protect a promise of a cure, a successful surgery or any other clinical outcome. Draft the arrangement as a financial remedy, not a clinical guarantee, and review it under both federal fraud-and-abuse law and applicable state professional-conduct rules. Put the terms in writing, confirm fair market value, remove referral and lock-in features, address reporting, and make sure the practice does exactly what the document says. Warranty the refund—not the result.
See: 42 C.F.R. § 1001.952(g); 42 U.S.C. §§ 1320a-7b(b), 1320a-7a(a)(5); OIG Advisory Opinion No. 26-12 (May 22, 2026).
Hi Jennifer,
Can I offer a warranty on my services?
Thanks,
Dr. J
Answer:
So, maybe. The warranty safe harbor is the star of today’s show. It is a regulatory exception to the Federal Anti-Kickback Statute for a bona fide warranty that meets specific conditions. In plain English, a provider or seller may promise to replace an item or service—or refund some or all of its cost—if the promised result is not achieved. If the warranty satisfies the safe harbor, the refund is not treated as illegal remuneration under the Anti-Kickback Statute. See 42 C.F.R. § 1001.952(g).
Ironically, a clinician who “warrants” a treatment result may be inviting a professional-misconduct charge. Yet federal fraud-and-abuse law has a safe harbor expressly built around a “warranty.” Put differently: the licensing rules warn, “Do not guarantee the outcome,” while the federal regulation says, “If you are going to refund the money when the outcome falls short, here is how to do it.” The safe harbor does not make a clinical guarantee permissible. It protects a carefully structured financial remedy, not a promise that treatment will work. Same word; very different legal consequence. For a discussion of the ethical and legal hazards of clinical guarantees, see “Caveat Promisor: The Potential Pitfalls of Clinical Guarantees.”
That protection matters because a refund has value, and anything of value offered to a patient can raise fraud-and-abuse questions. Calling a payment a “warranty” does not solve the problem. The arrangement has to operate like a real warranty: it must be in writing, state what is covered, explain the remedy, be part of the original bargain, and satisfy applicable disclosure and reporting requirements. It also cannot be a disguised reward for referrals or a hook that forces the patient to buy more services.
In OIG Advisory Opinion 26-12, the structure carried the day. The orthopedic surgeon offered a voluntary, one-year concierge program tied to recovery from an initial surgery. Patients enrolled before surgery under a written Membership Agreement and paid fair market value for non-covered services and products. A patient who substantially complied with the program but still required revision surgery within two years would receive a refund of the concierge fee. The refund was not tied to referrals. The patient was free to use another surgeon for the revision. There was no exclusivity or minimum-purchase requirement. The written agreement made the warranty part of the deal from the start and addressed the required reporting. Those facts allowed OIG to conclude that the arrangement fit the warranty safe harbor and would not generate prohibited remuneration under the Anti-Kickback Statute or the Beneficiary Inducements CMP.
Bottom line: The government has created a warranty safe harbor for a profession that generally should not be warranting results. That is the punchline—but not a loophole. The safe harbor may protect the refund; it does not protect a promise of a cure, a successful surgery or any other clinical outcome. Draft the arrangement as a financial remedy, not a clinical guarantee, and review it under both federal fraud-and-abuse law and applicable state professional-conduct rules. Put the terms in writing, confirm fair market value, remove referral and lock-in features, address reporting, and make sure the practice does exactly what the document says. Warranty the refund—not the result.
See: 42 C.F.R. § 1001.952(g); 42 U.S.C. §§ 1320a-7b(b), 1320a-7a(a)(5); OIG Advisory Opinion No. 26-12 (May 22, 2026).
