Question:

Hi Jennifer,

My prior employer is refusing to pay monies contractually owed.  What do we do now? 

Appreciate your input. 

Dr. I

Answer:

Yep.  Decent humans with reasonable risk palates often hesitate and/or are adverse to filing a lawsuit because they do not want their names associated with litigation, and/or cannot tolerate the purgatory of an unknown outcome inevitable with litigation. 

Completely understandable—but not every lawsuit carries the same stigma.

A lawsuit involving allegations of discrimination, harassment, patient harm or professional misconduct may require considerable explanation - messy. A lawsuit to collect earned compensation or enforce a contract is different.

The explanation is simple: You owed me money. You did not pay. I sued.

When a former employer, partner or business associate refuses to honor a financial obligation, the available options are generally:

  1. Continue negotiating;
  2. Prepare a complaint and send it before filing (basically, threaten litigation but show you may be bluffing); or
  3. File the lawsuit.

Filing is usually the most assertive option. It establishes deadlines, changes the dynamic and often brings the other side to the table quickly.

Yes, litigation is public. Yes, there may be a perceived stigma associated with suing. But the stigma is considerably less when the dispute concerns money and contractual obligations—not allegations about your character or professional conduct.

Best guidance I can give after 2 decades of practice - do not give up a legitimate claim solely because you are concerned someone may see the case.   

Bottom line: Sometimes the lawsuit is easily explained. Sometimes it is also the only language the other side understands.  It may be time to file... we can discuss.